Labor migration in the EU: Bulgaria between brain drain and brain gain

Labor migration in the EU: Bulgaria between brain drain and brain gain

The free movement of people within the European Union has changed the labor markets and allows citizens to move to where they see the best opportunities for work. But for countries like Bulgaria, this mobility poses a double challenge: brain drain, the loss of skilled labor, and the potential for brain gain, the return of talent and knowledge. Since joining the EU in 2007, labor migration has had a profound impact on the country and is one of the biggest socio-economic challenges.

The Brain Drain Phenomenon

The brain drain phenomenon in Bulgaria

Bulgaria is one of the regions most affected by the brain drain worldwide. Since 1990, the country has lost around 22 percent of its population, and forecasts point to a further decline of 23 percent by 2050. The population has shrunk by over one million people since 1989, from 7.9 million to 6.4 million in 2024. This decline is also reflected in the annual population change rate: as shown in chart 1, this rate has been negative since the mid-1980s (1985: -0.08%) and reached its lowest point at -1.21% around 1993/1994. In 2024 it will still be -0.61%, for 2025 a rate of between -0.6% and -0.83% is forecast, and by 2050 it will remain negative at -0.89%. This development is largely driven by low birth rates, high mortality rates and, above all, emigration.

World Population Prospects. (o. D.).

Causes of Migration: The Pull of the West and Internal Problems

The main causes of emigration lie in the significant economic disparities within the EU. Bulgarians leave their country in search of higher wages, better job security, and improved living conditions in Western Europe. Although the gross domestic product (GDP) per capita has increased from 1,625 USD in the year 2000 to 17,588 USD in 2024 and is projected to reach 24,894 USD by 2030, the absolute level remains low compared to the EU average—making emigration still an attractive option.

World Economic Outlook (WEO) Database.

The possibility of earning twice as much for the same work, or even getting more for less qualified work, is a strong incentive. In addition, there are internal problems such as corruption, weak public services, a lack of meritocracy, a poor work-life balance, a lack of professional development and outdated workplace cultures that encourage young people to leave.

Effects: Shortage of skilled workers and burden on the economy

The effects of the brain drain on Bulgaria are serious: it is leading to a decline in human capital, slowing economic growth and reducing productivity and tax revenues. Certain sectors have been hit particularly hard: the healthcare sector has been severely affected, with the number of doctors falling from 35,000 to 28,000 by 2017. Since 2007, over 15,000 Bulgarian doctors and 20,000 nurses have left the country, as a doctor in Germany can earn five to six times as much as a Bulgarian colleague. The IT sector is also suffering from the loss of qualified workers, who are migrating to countries with better salaries and career opportunities. Overall, the Bulgarian economy is predicted to face a shortage of around 400,000 qualified workers by 2017. This will lead to a shortage of skilled workers in construction, healthcare, education and engineering.

Profiteer Germany: The “transfer of wealth”

Germany benefits greatly from this development: it is the preferred destination country for Bulgarian migrants. In 2024, there were 371,128 Bulgarian citizens living in Germany alone, followed by Spain (112,834) and the Netherlands (60,494), which clearly shows the distribution in the EU.

Datenbank - Eurostat. (o. D.). Eurostat.

Many of them are better educated than average. Germany has a total of 8.9 million immigrant workers. Immigration from Eastern European countries has slowed down demographic change in Germany and helped to secure a supply of skilled workers. Without doctors from Eastern Europe, there would be no medical care at all in certain regions of Germany. This development is often referred to as a “transfer of wealth”, as countries such as Germany receive workers in whose training they did not have to invest.

The potential of brain gain for Bulgaria

Despite the challenges, labor migration also offers opportunities for Bulgaria, particularly through brain gain. This can take place in various ways: through the return of Bulgarians who have acquired new skills and knowledge abroad, or through the transfer of knowledge and capital through the Bulgarian diaspora.

In fact, there is an increasing tendency to return to Bulgaria, which has increased especially during the COVID-19 pandemic. Data from the National Statistical Institute (NSI) confirms a steady increase in returnees over the last decade. Bulgaria has a high proportion of migrants who are nationals, which indicates significant return mobility. These returnees can bring new knowledge, skills and innovations to the country, build networks and establish international contacts. Remittances are an important aspect of capital transfers: As shown in Figure 5, between around USD 115 million (in 2015) and over USD 420 million (in 2024) flowed annually from Bulgarian migrants to Bulgaria between 2014 and 2024. This shows a significant increase, with the highest value in 2024.

World Development Indicators | DataBank. (o. D.).

Examples of successful returnees or initiatives that promote brain gain are crucial.

Strategies to promote brain gain

In order to minimize brain drain and fully exploit the potential of brain gain, targeted measures are required at various levels.

The Bulgarian government has begun to develop strategies aimed at the return of its citizens. The National Migration Strategy of the Republic of Bulgaria (2021-2025) provides for programs to support returnees and promotes campaigns to encourage return. These include financial incentives, job search and integration support and the promotion of business start-ups by returnees. A key element is also the granting of Bulgarian citizenship based on descent in order to strengthen ties with the diaspora.

It is also important to strengthen ties with the Bulgarian diaspora in order to promote knowledge exchange and foreign investment. On a broad level, working conditions and salaries must be improved domestically. Investment in education and research as well as the fight against corruption and strengthening the rule of law are also essential to make the country more attractive. EU cohesion policy plays an important role here in reducing economic and social disparities between the regions.

Conclusion and outlook

Bulgaria faces the complex task of stemming the ongoing brain drain while at the same time harnessing the potential of return migration. The phenomenon of brain drain is directly attributable to the existing socio-economic imbalances within the EU, and although the EU institutions have introduced mechanisms to reduce these disparities, these have so far only been partially effective.

A holistic approach that includes both measures to stem the brain drain and to promote brain gain is crucial. This requires cooperation between politics, business, the education system and civil society in Bulgaria as well as a dialog between the countries of immigration and emigration. Although the brain drain of doctors is not a pressing problem at present, innovative funding approaches could be considered in the future if shortages in key professions occur.

Return mobility could be a possible solution to Bulgaria’s demographic crisis, although it has decreased since 2020. With targeted policy interventions, Bulgaria can further improve the benefits of migration and reduce the risks. The country has the potential to minimize the brain drain and benefit from the brain gain if it succeeds in creating attractive prospects at home and strengthening ties with its expatriate population.

Unemployment in Bulgaria 2023

Unemployment in Bulgaria 2023

Unemployment in Bulgaria continues to be a significant issue in 2023. Despite the country’s slow economic growth in recent years, the COVID-19 pandemic has led to the closure of many businesses, resulting in a further increase in unemployment.

Situation has improved over the past year.

In March 2023, the unemployment rate in Bulgaria is projected to be around 3.7 percent (compared to 4.5 percent in March 2022), according to the latest data from the European statistical authority, EUROSTAT. While this rate may not be very high compared to other EU countries, the number of long-term unemployed individuals is a cause for concern. Many people are struggling to find jobs, especially in rural areas and regions with lower economic development.

However, there have been positive developments as well. The Bulgarian government has launched various initiatives to promote employment, including support for start-up companies and the creation of incentives for job-creating businesses. Training and retraining programs have also been implemented to enhance employment opportunities for the unemployed.

The government is also committed to developing infrastructure, particularly in remote regions, to facilitate job creation in these areas. Another important step is to increase investment in the technology and service sectors, as these industries have high growth potential.

Unemployment in Sofia almost non existing

In major booming regions, particularly in the capital city of Sofia, as well as Plovdiv, Burgas, or Varna, unemployment is not a major issue. Qualified workers are in high demand, and there is nearly full employment. Sofia, with its emerging IT industry, and Plovdiv, with a strong industrial base, are experiencing widespread shortages of skilled workers.

In these major growth centers, such as the bustling capital of Sofia and the industrial hubs of Plovdiv, Burgas, and Varna, the unemployment situation is not a significant concern. Skilled workers are in high demand, and there is nearly full employment. Sofia, with its thriving IT sector, and Plovdiv, with its robust industrial base, are grappling with a widespread shortage of highly skilled professionals.

Efforts to address the unemployment issue extend beyond these urban centers. The Bulgarian government recognizes the need to bolster employment opportunities in rural areas and regions with lower economic development. Consequently, they have implemented various measures to uplift these areas. One crucial aspect involves investing in infrastructure development, particularly in remote regions, which not only improves connectivity but also facilitates job creation.

Additionally, the government has prioritized increasing investments in the technology and service sectors, acknowledging their immense growth potential. By fostering innovation and entrepreneurship in these industries, Bulgaria aims to generate new job opportunities and boost economic prosperity.

Moreover, the government has introduced programs aimed at fostering a skilled workforce. These initiatives include vocational training and retraining programs designed to enhance the employability of the unemployed. By equipping individuals with in-demand skills and qualifications, these programs strive to bridge the gap between job seekers and available employment opportunities.

While progress has been made, it is crucial to continue supporting and promoting initiatives that combat unemployment in Bulgaria. Collaboration between government entities, businesses, and communities is vital to ensure sustained economic growth and reduced unemployment rates throughout the country.

In conclusion, although unemployment remains a significant challenge in Bulgaria, positive steps have been taken to address the issue. The government’s commitment to promoting employment, investing in infrastructure, and fostering growth in key sectors demonstrates a proactive approach. However, ongoing efforts and support from various stakeholders are essential to further alleviate unemployment and create a thriving job market for all Bulgarians.

Austrian experts on Bulgaria in “Wirtschaftsblatt”

Austrian experts on Bulgaria in “Wirtschaftsblatt”

Zname-Avstria-300x200For more than a century Bulgaria and Austria have an intensive political , economical and cultural cooperation. Especially Austrian companies benefit from a good knowledge of the Bulgarian market. Not only for that reason Austria is the second largest investor of the country. The November issue of the Bulgarian Wirtschaftsblatt focuses on Austria. We have summarized and supplemented some interesting information.

Ambassador Hauser about Bulgaria as an investment country

A steady economical growth, an attractive tax environment as well as decreasing unemployment figures convince investors. Bulgaria has a strong amicable relationship with the German-speaking countries Germany, Switzerland and Austria, ambassador Mr. Mag. Roland Hauser towards Wirtschaftsblatt.

According to him, Bulgaria is at the moment in a phase of relative political stability which strengthens the confidence of Bulgaria as a business location.

Trade expert Straka: Bulgaria is stable!

The Austria trade commissioner in Sofia, Ms. Mag. Ulrike Straka agrees. According to her, Bulgaria has again politically more stable circumstances and there is an EU-friendly government – these are good preconditions. This leads to the fact that already located Austria commercial enterprises continue investing which attracts foreign investors.

But also negative trends on behalf of the government are noticeable, like the rejection of the Anti-corruption Law. Nevertheless in 2014 there has been direct foreign investment in Bulgaria from Austria in the amount of 290,7 mil €. Nearly 10% of the biggest foreign investors are companies from Austria like TelekomAustria, EVN, UniCredit/BankAustria, Knauf, Raiffeisen, OMV, REWE/Billa, WienerStädtischeVersicherung, UNIQA, Strabag and VAE. The popularity can also be seen in tourism. In 2014 174,899 Austrian nationals have visited Bulgaria, an 39.4% increase in comparison to 2013.

Bulgarians at the business location Austria

Conversely there is also interest. The Austrian market is highly coveted among Bulgarian businessmen. The good business climate, the qualified personnel and modern infrastructure, the strategic location between east and west, excellent living conditions as well as a high level of personal, political and legal safety and stability are deciding factors.

According to Straka Bulgarian businessmen are known to be friendly, appreciate Austria and Austrian companies and are highly interested in a cooperation.

In comparison to the Austrians the Bulgarians prefer to import a finished product. The reasons are high labour costs and taxes. Because of that mainly small offices are opened in Austria and simultaneously the favourable-priced Bulgarian resources are used. Also the worldwide known Bulgarian company Walltopia, which is famous for the production of climbing walls, is now doing active business in Austria for more that three years.

According to Hauser the future aim is to maintain the excellent relationship between these two countries through as many concrete projects as possible. He exemplary names the joint preparation for the presidency of the European Union which will be exercised by Bulgaria and Austria successively in 2018/19 as well as the 20th jubilee of the Austrian Music Weeks in Bulgaria 2016.

Roland Hauser

Ambassador  Mag. Roland Hauser (Source: Austrian Embassy in Sofia)

Mag. Roland Hauser finished historical studies, Romance philology studies, philosophy studies as well as his degree study program at the diplomatic academy Vienna. After being Austrian ambassador in Qatar, Kenya and Kuwait he is now ambassador of the Republic Austria in Bulgaria since September 2014. He describes his indeed positive Bulgarian impressions in the latest issue of the Wirtschaftsblatt.

Unemployment in Bulgaria 2011 to 2013

Unemployment in Bulgaria 2011 to 2013

The continuously high unemployment rate in Bulgaria has proven to be a persistent problem, but this is no exception to the general trend in Europe. In the following lines, we will try to go into some details concerning the latest labour trend, which we have posted earlier about: https://blog.balkaninvest.eu/weiter-hohe-arbeitslosigkeit-in-bulgarien/

How the phenomenon is being measured?

The unemployment rate is the percentage of unemployed from the total number of civilian work force, which is basically defined by the population size. The unemployment rate is an essential part of the unemployment statistics, because it is an indicator of the labour market and entire employment situation.

The data presented below is based on research of the Bulgarian Institute for Statistics and provides information about how unemployment has developed within the period 2011-2013.

Unemployment in Bulgaria 2011-2013

Unemployment in Bulgaria 2011-2013

Trends on Bulgaria’s labour-market

For 2011, the unemployment rate of the population aged 15 to 64 years is 11.4% and this percentage is continuously increasing over time. Until 2013 the share of unemployed people in the same age group has increased by 1.6%. It should be noted that this rate is always 2 to 3% higher for men than for women.

According to the figures supplied by the National Statistics Institute, in 2011 the unemployment rate of the population aged 15 to 29 amounts to 19.1%. In the following year this percentage has increased to 20.8% and in 2013 it reached a peak of 21.8% .

2013 in quarters

In order to represent the tendency more detailed, we will divide the year 2013 into quarters. In the first quarter of 2013, unemployment rate in Bulgaria was 13.8%. Subsequently, a decrease is recorded down to 12% in the third quarter. During the last three months, the rate has increased again by 1%. If we analyze the data by age, it is noticeable that the highest unemployment rate – 28.4% – is being observed among the representatives of the group 15-24 years, i.e. amongst the youngest working-population. In contrast, only 10.1% of the labour force aged 35-54 are unemployed.

Unemployment in Bulgaria 2011 to 2013

Upturn on labour market in Bulgaria

The Bulgarian labour market is gradually picking up, reports the National Employment Agency. During the current year 2013, over 178 thousand people have started a new job. The sheer number of workers who have acquired their jobs thanks to an employment program of the Agency has climbed by twenty thousand in comparison with the previous year.

35 psychologists and qualified managers have already been assigned in the job centres of all regional cities. They have the responsibility to professionally assist the job-seekers with overcoming their psychological barriers and gaining more self-confidence. Kamelia Nikolova, one of the psychologists at the employment office explained: “Most of the people who come to us are insecure and frustrated. Very often they have even lost their hope of ever finding a job”.

The currently employed psychologists and managers were initially registered as unemployed themselves. For this reason, they should be considered as an example of how the shortage of vacancies can be overcome, of course, not without the necessary motivation and support. To the measures undertaken by the Ministry of Labour and Social policy belongs also the Program for activation of unemployed with an yearly budget of 600 thousand Leva. However, the labour market still has to face the challenge to provide adequate working positions for qualified young people. This involves a long-term strategic planning, as well as a much stronger cooperation between companies and educational institutions.

A specific action aimed at such a result is the Ministry of Education Program for student internships, which strives to create a symbiosis between universities and business. Meanwhile, it was announced that the most desired occupations for the current year would be those of accountants, system administrators and sales representatives. This show the results of a survey carried out by the consulting companies CareerBuilder and Economic Modeling Specialists Intl. (EMSI).

Unemployment in Bulgaria 2011 to 2013

OECD criticizes Germany over low high-skilled immigration rate

The publication of an OECD report on the immigration of foreign workers to the German labor market has prompted keen media interest over the last few days.

After we reported only last week about the lack of sufficient interest of German IT companies to searching for qualified staff abroad, we are now presenting a comprehensive economical study of the OECD (Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development).

The study describes that the access to the German labor market as relatively easy (compared to other OECD member countries). Yet numbers suggest that in Germany, in spite of the alleged shortage of skilled workers, the market share of labor migrants from outside the EU and the European Free Trade Area (EFTA) accounts for a fifth and even tenth of the share of other studied countries such as Australia, Denmark, Canada and the United Kingdom.

SMEs account for considerable difficulties with migrant workers

The situation with Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) could be described as problematic. These types of businesses often encounter serious difficulties in finding suitable staff from abroad, which is apparent from the graph illustrating the results of the surveyed companies. .

Indeed, the shortage of skill workers is far more common in SMEs than in larger firms,

In contrast to big companies, SMEs have no international intercompany personnel exchange to facilitate recruitment of expat employees.Therefore the report recommends employers – especially SMEs – put more effort into looking for qualified personnel aboard if they cannot meet their need for skilled workers on the local labor market, the OECD says.

One of the many explanations of the problematic situation is that both at home and aboard the German immigration system is perceived as restrictive and difficult to access, argues the OECD report.

OECD recommends coining of an immigration strategy

Yves Leterme, Deputy Secretary-General of the OECD, advised for a consistent immigration policy during the presentation of the study on 4 February 2013 in Berlin. Without such an approach, meeting the projected shortage of skilled workers would be difficult: ‘The prosperity of Germany is largely dependent on whether it will be able to stay competitive despite its aging population.’

Read the full OEDC study ‘Immigration of foreign workers: Germany’ by clicking on the PDF thumb below.